Consumer Psychology in the Time of COVID-19

Tim LawtonMar 26 2020
Consumer Psychology in the Time of COVID-19

Key Highlights as of March 20th

  • Overwhelming majority of respondents, 76%, think the U.S. is headed towards a recession
  • Those who “trust that the government will take care of” them are up to 38% more likely to increase spending across all consumer categories
  • 34% (+6%) of consumers expect business conditions to improve in 6 months, but 42% (+10%) expect employment conditions to worsen in 6 months with fewer jobs

From worldwide lockdowns to government interventions and mandated work from home policies, the Coronavirus, or COVID-19, has impacted nearly every person on the globe. 

At home in the U.S., debates rage from state to state and with the Federal government on how to best address the needs of public health, the economy, and the consumer.

The current situation has been compared to the 2008-2009 financial crisis, and while experts can’t yet tell the full scale of the impacts of this current crisis, one thing is already certain: main street and the everyday consumer has already been significantly affected. 

Because consumer research and understanding the ever-changing sentiments and behaviors of consumers is even more important now, SightX set out to find out just how consumers were faring and how businesses can best respond during these challenging times. In our study, we received responses from 510 U.S. based consumers, representative of the U.S. general population. Insights presented here are reflective of the U.S. market from March 18th to the 20th.

Fear, Uncertainty, and Doubt

Unease is settling over consumers quicker in this current situation because it has touched all aspects of the economy at the onset, not just financial institutions. 

  • 77% of consumers are worried about COVID-19 “impacting their personal lives”
  • 76% agree that the U.S. is “headed into a recession”

And, in that context…

  • 52% said they were “satisfied with the U.S. President’s handling of the situation,” yet;
  • Only 37% trust that “the government (federal or state) would take care of them”

How will consumers respond?

In uncertain times, businesses and consumers alike will adapt their behavior in a variety of ways. Unfortunately, some recent behavioral changes have been mandated with top down ripple effects already being felt across almost all industries. 

Because consumer sentiment in these times is changing, almost daily, our aim was to get at expectations of spending on different consumer categories two to four weeks out. We found that 69% of consumers were “actively planning on reducing personal spending” in general, in the immediate future.

  • As you can imagine, live entertainment (54%) and travel (51%) were categories most expecting a reduction in spending
  • A close third in our study was apparel & footwear (42%), however an equal number of respondents (42%) were expecting no change in their spend in that category

Decrease Spending (%)

  • Areas of expected increase in spending were non-perishable foods (59%), household goods (49%), snack/sweets (43%), and perishable foods (42%)

Increase Spending (%)


We followed up by examining group differences in consumer behavior, including gender, income level and age groups.

There weren’t any major differences across income levels and gender, where overall the same trends and distributions of spending behaviors were the same. The highest percentile difference across income levels was only 5%. 

Respondents aged 18 to 54 years old expressed more of a tendency to change spending habits, either an increase or decrease across categories, versus respondents who were 55 years old and above.

Older respondents were more likely to keep spending habits the same.

Where we are and where we’re going

Consumer confidence, to a large degree informs economic planning and activity. So we asked consumers about their assessment of the general conditions of business and employment in the U.S., now and 6 months hence.

The good news is that consumers generally expect the business conditions in the U.S. to improve in 6 months with only 43% (-9%).

Although even in that context, 42% (+10%) said they have an expectation of “fewer jobs.”

So, what does drive behavior?

In addition to behavioral conditions, we examined several general psychological mindsets and world views that consumers have, to include self-agency, optimism, trusting that governments and states take care of their citizens, importance of luck in ones’ life, the goodness of humanity, and its rationality.

This was done with the goal of analyzing potential psychological drivers of consumer behavior.

The two most powerful insights uncovered were related to two variables: a person’s sense of self-agency (does luck dictate my life or not?), and ones’ trust that the government (federal and/or state) will take care of their citizens.  

With the question of “I trust that the government (federal and/or state) will take care of me,” measured with a 5-point scale, top and bottom buckets were determined and compared on likelihood of increase in spending across each consumer category.

Those who “trust that the government will take care of” them are up to 38% more likely to increase spending across all consumer categories.

With the question of “In general, I think one’s life trajectory is about luck,” also measured with a 5-point scale, top and bottom buckets were determined and compared on likelihood of increase in spending across each consumer category.  

Those who had lower sense of agency, they think luck plays a big role in their lives, were significantly more likely to increase their spending, versus those who had higher self-agency (as opposed to random luck), who were more likely to buckle down on spending.

Those two psychological variables were the most powerful predictors of who is more likely to alter spending habits, much more so than any other demographic or control variable, including gender, income, or age group. 

This preliminary study suggests that some of the strongest indicators of consumer behavior in this particularly challenging COVID-19 environment are actually driven by consumer psychology and mindset rather than a specific consumer demographic. 

Tim Lawton

Tim Lawton

Ready to meet the next generation
of market research technology?

More from SightX

Four Graphic Elements: Siggy the animated purple SightX owl surfs a wave. A podium with a trophy. The Olympic rings. A bar graph with Olympic research data displayed.

Insights: 2020 Tokyo Olympics

After a long wait, the 2020 Tokyo Olympics have (finally) arrived! 

by Savannah Trotter

Insights: Exploring Cancel Culture & Redemption

Avoiding transgressors is hardwired into the human brain. Since early groups of people began to form communities, turning away from those who caused harm has been used as an effective form of societal punishment. 

by Savannah Trotter
Half the Story Means Half the Knowledge

What the Fundamental Attribution Error Means for Marketers

In the last half-century, social psychologists have demonstrated time and time again that contextual factors are stronger predictors of human behavior than personality variables. 

by Naira Musallam, PhD

Research Services